Issue 44.13
A number of people have been waiting for a review of the new version of Windows 8 – called 8.1. While it has some redeeming features, I have to say that, if you hated Windows 8, you will hate 8.1 as well. If you liked 8, you will like 8.1 even more.
The basic problem for most people is the total change of direction Microsoft made when it introduced the new Operating System. Microsoft has decided that the best system for you is one that mirrors how people use their cell phone – touching the screen, sliding tiles around and using apps (applications) instead of programs. Many of the apps offered are “cloud” based, meaning that they are partially or completely stored online instead of in your computer. If you lose connection to the internet for any reason, you lose access to the program or many of the capabilities it has. It also assumes that you have a touch screen and is difficult to use smoothly if your monitor or laptop does not have this feature.
The reasons they have taken this approach are confusing, but two obvious and likely thoughts are that 1) they give Microsoft control over your software. They can turn it off or change it when they choose, making you dependent on them. 2) They make more money if you have to buy new software or update for a fee when they decide. Many of the new programs are charging a monthly fee to “use” them rather than a one-time purchase.
In an effort to please those of us that like the way Windows worked with XP and Windows 7, Microsoft has included a “desktop” tile that sends you to a screen similar to Windows 7 and has some of the same features. Sadly, it is a clunky and limited version of those desktops. The new revision has restored some of the features we are used to such as the “start” button which can take you to look at your printer setup, control panel (very limited version) and lists of programs. I had hoped that the revision, 8.1, would give us more control and make more of the older programs we use accessible, but it doesn’t seem to do that very well. There are some cool new features, for example you can tile programs on your screen and they can work at the same time. Some of the apps are well thought out and comfortable to use. Apps take less power to run (usually) and so they run faster. There are other things I like. Overall, however, I am still less than pleased with the approach and direction they are taking.
I also have a tablet with 8.1 RT as the OS. RT is a stripped down version of 8 designed to run with less powerful computers, and I had hoped that it would be strengthened. Sadly, most of the improvements in 8.1 were not included in RT.
Over all, my recommendation is still that, if you are comfortable with smart phones and want to check out Windows 8, take the time to use someone else’s computer with this system or try one at the store and see if you actually like it or can use it comfortably before you upgrade your computer or purchase a new one. Many who didn’t take the time to try before they buy have called me to ask what they can do with their new “paper weight”. Windows 7 computers are getting hard to buy, but working with an independent IT person like me, you can still get them. Upgrading your current computer to 7 is also a possibility and may be your best approach if you are still using XP or Vista, since support for them is rapidly disappearing.
While you decide what is best for you, remember to always back up anything that is important to you.
Shaun McCausland has worked in the computer industry for over 32 years, 23 years of it locally with Bits ‘N’ Bytes and Musicomp and currently does in-home and on-site computer consultation, service, training and repair. If you have questions you can reach him at 435-668-7118 or his website www.bitsnbytescom